top of page
Thin Stripes

Practice Areas

Insurance Defense

Insurance defense has been and will always be central to the litigation practice at Metzger Rosta LLP, and each attorney at Metzger Rosta LLP has a significant background in representing numerous insurance carriers and their respective insureds.

​

Metzger Rosta LLP has handled and tried cases in nearly every one of Indiana’s ninety-two (92) counties, and we have handled insurance defense cases in both federal and state courts throughout the state.

The interior of a courtroom with judges bench and two sitting areas flanking its sides.

Expert Representation

Metzger Rosta LLP has a significant background in representing numerous insurance carriers and their respective insureds.

​

Representative insurance clients include the following:

​

  • Illinois Farmers Insurance Company

  • Bristol West Insurance Company

  • GEICO Direct

  • Society Insurance

  • CNA Insurance Companies

  • Chubb Specialty Commerce Insurance Company

  • American Family Insurance

  • Progressive Insurance Company

  • T.H.E. Insurance Company

 

Should you desire references from any of these insurance carriers or from any of our self-insureds or corporate clients, we would be pleased to provide you with a list of claims professionals or managers with whom you would be free to contact.

Understanding the Case

A majority of our work involves representation of insurers and insureds in lawsuits involving a number of different types of cases which include:

​

  • Medical, Legal and other Professional Malpractice Claims

  • Defense of Real Estate Brokers and Sales Agents

  • Motor Vehicle Accidents

  • Wrongful Death Claims

  • Compromise of Minor Settlement Claims

  • Products Liability Claims

  • Premises Liability Claims

  • Defense of Schools and Municipalities in a broad range of matters

​

Metzger Rosta LLP has handled and tried cases in nearly every one of Indiana’s ninety-two (92) counties, and we have handled insurance defense cases in both federal and state courts throughout the state, as well as before administrative agencies and other tribunals.

 

Our insurance defense attorneys are experienced not only in trying cases before judges, juries and administrative tribunals, but also in guiding our clients through arbitration and mediation proceedings in an attempt to seek a reasonable out of court settlement.

 

While we make every effort to resolve our client’s case prior to trial, our defense attorneys are experienced and highly skilled litigators and have the reputation throughout the state as attorneys with a phenomenal record of success.

OUR ATTORNEYS

Specialized in Insurance Defense
Headshot of founding partner Mark Metzger.

PARTNER

Mark Metzger

E: mark@metzgerrosta.com

P: (317) 219-4610
LinkedIn  |  Attorney Profile

Headshot of founding partner Thomas Rosta.

PARTNER

Thomas Rosta
Headshot of partner Tammy Meyer.

PARTNER

Tammy Meyer
Headshot of attorney Catie Daly.

ATTORNEY

Catie Daly
Headshot of attorney Myranda McLean.

ATTORNEY

Myranda McLean
Headshot of attorney Jimmy Sedam.

ATTORNEY

Jimmy Sedam
Headshot of co-counsel and attorney Robert Taggart.

ATTORNEY :: CO-COUNSEL

Robert Taggart
Headshot of attorney Matthew Daly.

ATTORNEY

Matthew Daly

E: matt@metzgerrosta.com

P: (317) 316-0790
LinkedIn  |  Attorney Profile

CLIENTS WE HAVE WORKED WITH

West Bend Insurance logo.
Illinois Casualty Company Insurance logo.
Farmers Insurance logo.
AAA Insurance logo.
Spriska Insurance logo
Geico insurance logo.
Bristol West Insurance Group logo.
Zurich Insurance logo.
Progressive Insurance logo
Founders Insurance logo.
American Access Casualty Company logo.
Farm Bureau Insurance logo.
Society Insurance logo.
Foremost Insurance Group logo.
Erie Insurance logo.
The rotunda of the Noblesville Courthouse peaks over the tops of trees against blue skies and white clouds.

VERY FRIENDLY AND PERSONABLE.

They put you at ease. Easy to talk to. Definitely would recommend this law firm.

Stephani Scott

Receive a FREE Consultation

Our team of attorneys are ready to help you. Take the first step and fill out our contact form or contact us directly below.

(317) 219-4606

32 S. 9th Street, Noblesville, IN 46060

MetgerRostaLog2_edited.png
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Copyright  © 2026 Metzger Rosta LLP.  All Rights Reserved.

bottom of page